Vera Thornton Martha's Vineyard Real Estate
Vera Thornton Real Estate

Rental Property Details

The Captain Butler House
Listing ID: 8017
Price Range: $10,000 - $20,000
Town: Edgartown
Bedrooms: 6
Bathrooms: 6.5
Occupancy: 10
Availability: Year-round
Features: Swimming Pool
Air Conditioning

Inquiry about The Captain Butler House

Please fill in the form below:

To prevent spam robots from using this form please enter the validation numbers that you see on the right:   

Bedroom Configurations

#1:  2nd Floor - Queen Ensuite
#2:  2nd Floor - Queen Ensuite
#3:  2nd Floor - Queen Ensuite
#4:  3rd Floor  Two Twins Ensuite
#5:  Lower Level - Queen Ensuite
#6:  Carriage House - Queen Ensuite

Front Entrance from North Water Street 
scroll left
scroll right

Front Entrance from North Water Street

Patio Connecting Main House and Carriage House

Patio showing Fireplace

Rear of Home with Glimpse of Pool

Patio showing French Doors to Carriage House


Butler's Pantry

Kitchen Dining Area

Kitchen Lounge Area overlooking Pool

Formal Dining Room

Formal Living Room

Lower Level Ensuite Queen Bedroom

Second Floor Queen Ensuite

Bedroom 3: Second Floor Queen Ensuite

Bedroom 4: Second Floor Queen Ensuite

Bedroom 5: Third Floor with Two Twins

Bedroom 5 Sitting Area with Harborview

Queen Bath

The Captain Butler House

Comfort, luxury, and style are key details here.  The first floor offers lovely formal living room with fireplace and formal dining room with seating for eight.  The open kitchen area with counter seating, lounge area with casual dining, wet bar and 48" TV are a favorite spot.  Butler's pantry offers additional counter space and a second dishwasher. French doors open onto an inviting bluestone patio area with outdoor fireplace, game room, and heated 12x24' pool.  A portico connects the main house to the carriage house, where the second floor 6th bedroom features its own deck, which also connects to the house.

Main house second floor has three ensuite queen bedrooms; the master is at the rear of the house with stand alone soaking tub, glass shower for two, and deck overlooking the pool. Third floor features two built in toe-to-toe twin beds, sitting room, private bath, and lovely harbor view from petite balcony.  A spiral staircase leads to the widow's walk, where the Edgartown harbor views are glorious.

This premier home has a very strong rental history and early booking is encouraged.

General Information

4000 square feet
Central Air Conditioning
Gas/FHA Heat
Usable Fireplace
Pets Not Accepted
Smoking Not Allowed

Rental Information

Minimum Stay: 1 week
Check In: 4:00 pm Sunday
Check Out: 10:00 am Sunday
Security Deposit: $2500.
Administrative Fee: $50.
Exit Cleaning Fee: $400.
Ferry Tickets not included


Gas Range
Coffee Maker
Toaster Oven
Lobster Pot
Food Processor
Dining Capacity 12


High Speed Internet


Ironing Board
Linens Included


Television 4
Cable TV
DVD Player


Gas Grill
Deck Furniture
Outdoor Shower
Heated Private Pool
Wet Bar


Beach Chairs
Beach Umbrella